News & Media 5th Feb 2019

Budget 2019: Judicial Reform Is What This Economy Needs Now


Suhail Nathani Managing Partner | Mumbai

Latest Thought Leadership

Articles 14th Jun 2024

Digital Bouncers: Navigating the Digital Competition

Read More
Articles 14th Jun 2024

SEBI Imposes Financial Penalties on Market Infrastructure Institutions For Surveillance Failures

Read More
News & Media 13th Jun 2024

Compensation claims plunge as SEBI crackdown intensifies

Read More
News & Media 12th Jun 2024

50% assured pension for central govt staff under NPS: Proposal explained

Read More

Usually, a vote on account is a non-event in the cycle of India’s annual media event surrounding the budget. However, this year it was different for a few reasons: the jobs data—disputed or otherwise—just prior to the vote on account revealed an alarming trend in an economy already ravaged by demonetisation and the Goods and Services Tax; and of course, the impending elections.

To those who watched the budget speech, it was largely propaganda and sops. Everyone got a little bit and a promise for lots more to come, when the Finance Minister laid out his vision for the next ten years. Rural subsidies for poor farmers (Pradhan Mantri Kisan Samman Nidhi), salary deductions raised and income tax limit raised, a twenty-four-hour timeframe to process all income tax returns and the promise of anonymity between income tax assessor and assessee. Even a pension scheme for every Indian (Pradhan Mantri Shram-Yogi Maandhan).

India’s biggest growth engine is its aspiring middle class. This budget directly puts money into their hands and this is a huge positive. Historically, lofty government welfare schemes have been high on ambition and low on impact. While government schemes still remain (like Pradhan Mantri Jeevan Jyoti Bima Yojana and Pradhan Mantri Suraksha Bima Yojana) the shift to direct cash to the citizen needs to be lauded. This will clearly keep the consumption engine moving. Even the rationalisation of taxes around real estate ownership will have a positive impact on the real estate sector. Add to this the promise of GST reform for under construction flats in the near future and we will likely see a revival of the battered sector soon.

  • While political parties can vie for credit on various fronts, thankfully India keeps chugging along.

    A healthy monsoon and least interference from the government will serve the economy well. Aadhaar and the direct link to bank accounts facilitates this and we have the digital revolution to thank for that. The monsoon – well every year we can pray for that; and finally minimal government – we can only hope for that.

  • The Changes Needed In The Legal System

    One final point of view, the legal system needs to become a support and not an impediment in the growth of the economy. Today for numerous reasons, we are far from that. The Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code and uncertainty and delays in the resolution are bringing the much-needed reform to its knees.

    There is little doubt that the judiciary is having a tremendous impact on the economy. First, the government is the largest litigator in the courts. Decision making needs to be less arbitrary and laws need to be much clearer.

  • Today, decision-makers are almost incentivised to take no decisions and push the file, letting courts finally decide, thereby minimising any allegations of impropriety and post-decision inquiry.

    This must change. The next badly needed reform is the reform to the judiciary itself. An understaffed and overburdened judiciary with failing infrastructure can only go so far. There must be a large-scale revamp with the requisite budgetary allocations to bring about the change from outside.

    More important is the change from within. Appointments must be made on merit and the process must become more transparent. The tribunal system—NCLT, Green tribunal, SAT etc.—should be staffed by sector experts and the structure needs to be re-looked at in a manner that it is not overloaded with retired judges and bureaucrats. India is perhaps the only country in the world, where appointments to tr

  • Today, our Supreme Court is less a constitutional authority and more a court of last appeal.

    This is neither serving the populace not the economy. No budget can fix that.

    The judicial system needs to embrace technology. This does not mean digitisation of pleadings. It means the use of technology for small claims, non-criminal offences and routine non-contentious matters like probates and the like. The United Kingdom has adopted several of these reforms. Having inherited the common law system from them, there is no reason we cannot learn and adapt these technologies

    The poor implementation of GST and the ill-advised demonetisation were products of our political masters. The consequent and predictable impact on the economy hurts the average Indian. After the introduction of GST, its repair is still a work in progress.

  • The point is that India lumbers along notwithstanding the administrators.

    An ambitious population, and, hopefully, a bountiful annual monsoon will drive India.

    In sum, going forward, beyond the political grandstanding what India needs is early adoption of technology as an interface between citizens and the government—including administration and delivery of justice—and a minimal imposition of ideological thought through budgetary allocations, and the economy will do just fine. Scratch the surface and you will see beneath all the grand names of the variou

    Click here to read full article.